Looking for the complete Witches Brew menu with current prices? You’ve found the ultimate guide to this enchanting coffee house known for its magical atmosphere and exceptional vegan and vegetarian options.
The Witches Brew Coffee House has cast a spell on coffee lovers with signature items like the beloved Goat Cheese Crostini and an impressive selection of specialty espresso drinks. Whether you’re craving a hearty Falafel Sandwich or one of their famous Black Magic espresso creations, this comprehensive guide covers everything you need to know.
We’ll explore the complete menu categories, current pricing, dietary information, ordering options, and location details to help you plan your perfect Witches Brew experience.
Complete The Witches Brew Menu with Prices
Appetizers & Starters 🍽️
The Witches Brew appetizers are perfect for sharing or starting your magical meal:
• Goat Cheese Crostini – $9.25
Toasted artisan bread topped with creamy goat cheese and fresh herbs. This customer favorite showcases the café’s commitment to quality ingredients. (V)
• Spinach & Artichoke Dip – $12.25
A warm, bubbling blend of spinach, artichokes, and melted cheeses served with fresh bread or crispy chips. This staff pick is perfect for sharing. (V)
Both appetizers highlight the restaurant’s focus on vegetarian-friendly options that don’t compromise on flavor.
Fresh Salads 🥗
Witches Brew salads offer healthy, flavorful options for every dietary preference:
• Greek Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, crisp cucumbers, ripe tomatoes, red onions, bell peppers, Kalamata olives, and feta cheese tossed with olive oil and red wine vinaigrette.
• Kale Salad (Vegan)
Organic baby kale with grape tomatoes, carrot ginger dressing, golden raisins, sesame seeds, and toasted almonds. A nutrient-packed choice that’s both satisfying and healthy. (V)
These salads demonstrate the café’s expertise in creating dishes that cater to health-conscious diners, similar to other specialty establishments like Noir Kitchen Cocktail Menu Options.
Main Courses & Entrées 🍝
The heart of The Witches Brew menu features diverse entrées that blend Italian-American influences with creative vegan options:
• Pesto Gnocchi or Tomato Gnocchi – $13.95
Pillowy potato gnocchi served with your choice of fresh basil pesto or rich, slow-simmered tomato sauce. Currently trending among diners.
• Trofie Alfredo & Mushroom
Traditional Italian trofie pasta tossed in creamy alfredo sauce with sautéed mushrooms. Contact restaurant for current pricing.
Vegan Main Courses:
• Falafel Sandwich (Vegan)
House-made falafel with hummus, tahini sauce, lettuce, tomato, and cucumber served on warm pita bread. A top vegan pick that’s both filling and flavorful. (V)
• Kale Tofu Stir Fry (Vegan, Gluten-Free)
Tender organic kale and crispy tofu stir-fried with aromatic spices, served over brown rice. Perfect for health-conscious diners. (V, GF)
• Garden Burger (Vegan)
House-made black bean and quinoa patty with shredded carrots, celery, and onions on a whole wheat bun with lettuce, tomato, and onion. (V)
Sides & Bagel Options 🥯
Witches Brew sides include various bagel options with creative spreads:
• Tofu Cream Cheese – $3.50
A dairy-free alternative that’s rich and creamy. (V)
• Butter Cinnamon & Sugar – $5.00
Sweet and comforting classic combination.
• Peanut Butter & Toasted Vegan Marshmallow – $6.25
A unique twist that’s both nostalgic and plant-based. (V)
• Vegan Mozzarella and Peppers – $6.25
Savory option with melted dairy-free cheese and roasted peppers. (V)
Beverages ☕
The Witches Brew drink menu is where the magic truly happens, featuring an extensive selection of coffee and tea creations:
Coffee & Espresso:
• Organic Coffee with Steamed Milk – $3.50
Smooth, fair-trade organic coffee with your choice of steamed milk.
• Specialty Espresso Drinks – $6.00 each
An enchanting collection including:
- Aloha Mocha – Tropical twist on classic mocha
- Black Cat – Bold espresso creation
- Black Widow – Intense coffee experience
- Black Magic – The signature Witches Brew specialty
- Blue Angel – Unique blended creation
- Broomstick – Whimsical coffee concoction
- Halloween – Seasonal favorite
- Ghost – Creamy white coffee blend
- Heaven – Smooth, heavenly combination
Milk Alternatives:
• Organic Milk Alternatives – $2.25 each
Choose from organic milk, soy, or almond milk for any beverage customization.
Like other specialty beverage establishments such as Gong Cha Brewed Tea Menu, The Witches Brew offers extensive customization options.
Desserts & Sweet Treats 🍨
• Sorbet & Tofutti – $4.75
Dairy-free ice cream alternatives perfect for ending your meal on a sweet note. (V)
The café also features many espresso drinks with dessert-like flavors that can satisfy your sweet tooth while providing a caffeine boost.
Most Popular The Witches Brew Items
Based on customer feedback and staff recommendations, these Witches Brew favorites consistently rank highest:
🥇 Goat Cheese Crostini – The undisputed customer favorite that showcases the café’s attention to quality ingredients.
🥈 Vegan Falafel Sandwich – The top vegan pick that proves plant-based doesn’t mean sacrificing flavor.
🥉 Black Magic Espresso – The signature drink that embodies the Witches Brew mystique.
Trending Items:
- Pesto Gnocchi – Currently the most popular main course
- Kale Tofu Stir Fry – Top choice for health-conscious diners
- Aloha Mocha – Rising star among specialty drinks
These popular choices demonstrate why The Witches Brew has built such a loyal following among both coffee enthusiasts and food lovers.
The Witches Brew Prices & Value Analysis
Witches Brew pricing offers excellent value for the quality and portion sizes:
Price Ranges:
- Appetizers: $9.25 – $12.25
- Main Courses: $13.95 (average)
- Beverages: $3.50 – $6.00
- Bagel Options: $3.50 – $6.25
- Desserts: $4.75
The pricing structure reflects the café’s commitment to organic and high-quality ingredients. Compared to similar coffee houses like Caribou Coffee Brewed Drinks Menu, The Witches Brew offers competitive pricing for specialty beverages.
Best Value Items:
- Organic Coffee with Steamed Milk at $3.50 offers premium quality at an accessible price
- Specialty Espresso Drinks at $6.00 provide unique flavors you won’t find elsewhere
- Pesto Gnocchi at $13.95 delivers a substantial, restaurant-quality meal
Budget-Friendly Options:
- Bagel options starting at $3.50
- Basic coffee drinks under $4.00
- Shareable appetizers perfect for groups
Nutrition & Dietary Information
The Witches Brew excels in accommodating various dietary needs with clear labeling:
Dietary Symbols:
- (V) – Vegetarian
- (V) – Vegan (when specified)
- (GF) – Gluten-Free
Vegan Options Include:
- Falafel Sandwich
- Kale Tofu Stir Fry
- Garden Burger
- Kale Salad
- Various vegan bagel spreads
- All sorbet and tofutti desserts
Gluten-Free Choices:
- Kale Tofu Stir Fry (served over rice)
- Greek Salad (without bread)
- Many beverage options
Allergy-Conscious Features:
- Multiple milk alternatives (soy, almond, organic milk)
- Nut-free options available
- Staff trained to discuss ingredients
The café encourages customers to ask about dietary customizations as many dishes can be modified to meet specific needs.
How to Order from The Witches Brew
Witches Brew ordering is convenient with multiple options available:
Online Ordering
- Official café website with online ordering system
- Mobile-friendly ordering interface
- Account creation for faster future orders
Phone Orders
- West Hempstead Location: +1 516-489-9482
- Call ahead for pickup times
- Phone orders accepted during business hours
Delivery Options
- DoorDash – Available in most service areas
- Uber Eats – Check local availability
- Delivery fees vary by service and location
- Minimum order requirements may apply
In-Store Experience
- Counter service with friendly staff
- Cozy seating for dine-in
- Free Wi-Fi for laptop users
- Mystical atmosphere perfect for meetings or studying
Payment Methods:
- All major credit cards accepted
- Apple Pay and Google Pay for contactless payment
- Cash accepted at physical locations
The Witches Brew Hours & Locations
Current Locations
West Hempstead, NY (Primary Location)
- Address: 311 Hempstead Tpke Unit B, West Hempstead, NY 11552
- Phone: +1 516-489-9482
- Status: Currently operating
Salem, MA Location
- Address: 156 Derby St, Salem, MA 01970-5677
- Status: Currently closed (as of 2025)
Operating Hours
Witches Brew hours vary by location. Contact the restaurant directly for current operating hours as they may change seasonally or for holidays.
Typical Hours: Most coffee house locations operate daily, but specific times should be verified by calling ahead.
Location Features
- Parking: Available at West Hempstead location
- Accessibility: Contact restaurant for accessibility information
- Seating: Indoor seating with cozy, mystical atmosphere
- Wi-Fi: Free internet access for customers
For the most accurate Witches Brew hours and location information, always call ahead or check the official website before visiting.
Current Deals & Promotions
Witches Brew deals and promotions are not extensively advertised online, but several opportunities exist:
Regular Promotions
- Seasonal Specials: Check for limited-time offerings during holidays
- Social Media Deals: Follow official social media accounts for flash promotions
- Newsletter Signup: Potential discounts for email subscribers
Loyalty Programs
Currently no official loyalty program information is available. Contact the restaurant directly to inquire about:
- Frequent customer discounts
- Birthday specials
- Student or senior discounts
Money-Saving Tips
- Happy Hour Pricing: Inquire about off-peak discounts
- Group Orders: Ask about discounts for large orders
- Combo Meals: Some locations may offer meal + drink combinations
Stay connected with The Witches Brew on social media for the latest deals and seasonal promotions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Does The Witches Brew deliver?
Yes, Witches Brew delivery is available through DoorDash and Uber Eats in most service areas. Delivery availability and fees vary by location.
What are the most popular menu items at The Witches Brew?
The most popular Witches Brew items include the Goat Cheese Crostini ($9.25), Vegan Falafel Sandwich, and Black Magic espresso drink ($6.00).
Are there vegetarian and vegan options?
Absolutely! The Witches Brew offers extensive vegan and vegetarian options including multiple main courses, sides, beverages, and desserts clearly marked with dietary symbols.
What are The Witches Brew hours?
Witches Brew hours vary by location. Contact the West Hempstead location at +1 516-489-9482 for current operating hours.
How much does delivery cost from The Witches Brew?
Delivery costs depend on your chosen service (DoorDash, Uber Eats) and distance from the restaurant. Check the delivery app for specific fees in your area.
Do they accept mobile payments?
Yes, The Witches Brew accepts Apple Pay, Google Pay, and all major credit cards for convenient payment.
Is there a kids menu available?
A specific kids menu is not detailed in current information. Contact the restaurant directly to inquire about child-friendly options and portions.
Can I customize drinks with different milk alternatives?
Yes! Witches Brew offers organic milk, soy milk, and almond milk alternatives for $2.25 each to customize any beverage.
What makes The Witches Brew different from other coffee shops?
The Witches Brew stands out with its mystical atmosphere, extensive vegan options, unique specialty drinks like Black Magic, and commitment to organic ingredients.
Conclusion
The Witches Brew menu offers a magical dining experience that perfectly blends specialty coffee culture with satisfying food options. From the beloved Goat Cheese Crostini to the innovative Black Magic espresso, every item reflects the café’s commitment to quality and creativity.
The extensive vegan and vegetarian options make it an inclusive destination for diners with various dietary preferences. With reasonable pricing ranging from $3.50 for coffee to $13.95 for main courses, The Witches Brew provides excellent value for high-quality, often organic ingredients.
Whether you’re ordering the trending Pesto Gnocchi, trying a unique espresso creation, or enjoying a healthy Kale Tofu Stir Fry, The Witches Brew delivers a memorable experience. The convenient ordering options including phone orders, online ordering, and delivery make it easy to enjoy these magical flavors wherever you are.
For the most current Witches Brew prices and menu availability, we recommend calling ahead or checking their official website. The West Hempstead location continues to serve the community with the same enchanting atmosphere and exceptional menu that has made The Witches Brew a local favorite.
Plan your visit today and discover why this mystical coffee house has cast a spell on so many satisfied customers!
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Prices may vary by location and are verified as of August 2025. For the most current pricing and availability, please contact the restaurant directly or visit their official website.
About AllTheMenus.com: We strive to provide accurate and up-to-date menu information. If you notice any errors or outdated information, please contact us so we can update our records.
