Chittenango Pizza Menu & Prices (2025) – Complete Guide
If you are craving authentic NY-style slices, spicy Chicken Riggies, or a hearty Friday Fish Fry in Madison County, the Chittenango Pizza menu is likely on your radar. Known for generous portions and a straightforward, flavor-first approach, this local spot has become a staple for residents looking for quality Italian-American comfort food without the fuss.
In this comprehensive guide, we break down the complete menu, including their famous popular dishes, wing sauces, and value-packed combo deals. Whether you are looking to feed a large party with a sheet pizza or just grabbing a quick lunch sub, we have organized everything you need to know about Chittenango Pizza prices and ordering options.
🍕 Specialty Pizzas
Chittenango Pizza offers pies in three main formats: By the slice, Medium (14″), and Large (18″). Their dough is hand-tossed, striking that balance between a crispy bottom and a chewy crust typical of New York-style pizzerias.
One of the standout features here is the variety of toppings. While you can build your own, their specialty combinations offer the best value for flavor lovers.
| Menu Item | Price (Med/Lg) | Description | Calories (Est/Slice) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Triple Meat ⭐ | $16.95 / $19.95 | A carnivore’s dream loaded with pepperoni, crispy bacon, and savory sausage. | 320-380 |
| Supreme | $17.45 / $20.45 | The full experience: roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, mushrooms, black olives, sausage, pepperoni, and bacon. | 310-360 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch | $16.45 / $19.45 | A white base topped with creamy ranch dressing, grilled chicken, and bacon crumbles. | 340-390 |
| Buffalo Chicken | $16.45 / $19.45 | Spicy buffalo sauce base with grilled chicken, blue cheese crumbles, and celery accents. | 300-350 |
| Veggie | $15.95 / $18.95 | Roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, mushrooms, black olives, and banana peppers. | 240-280 |
| Garlic Pizza | $14.95 / $17.95 | A classic white pizza with garlic butter, parmesan cheese, and fresh parsley. | 260-300 |
| Cheese | $13.95 / $16.95 | Traditional NY-style cheese pizza with house marinara. | 250-290 |
Topping Options: Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, grilled chicken, mushrooms, black olives, onions, banana peppers, red peppers, cherry peppers, blue cheese crumbles.
Add toppings: $1.50 (Medium) / $2.00 (Large)
🍗 Wings & Appetizers
In Upstate New York, pizza is rarely ordered without wings. The Chittenango Pizza menu features both traditional bone-in and boneless wings. They offer a wide spectrum of sauces, ranging from mild comfort to serious heat.
If you are looking for similar regional pizza-and-wing combinations, you might compare these offerings to the Sir Pizza menu prices to see how local competitors stack up.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Wings | $9.95 | One flavor choice. Served with blue cheese. | 800-1000 |
| 24 Wings | $17.95 | Up to two flavor choices. Great for sharing. | 1900-2400 |
| 40 Wings | $24.95 | The party bucket. Up to two flavors. | 3200+ |
| Chicken Tenders | $10.95 | Golden breaded chicken strips with dipping sauce. | 650 |
| Antipasto Salad | $12.95 | Romaine, roasted red peppers, banana peppers, onions, olives, capicola, salami, and provolone. | 550 |
Wing Sauces:
- Mild, Medium, Hot
- BBQ
- Sweet Chili
- Jerk
- Garlic Parmesan
- Everything Sauce (Customer Favorite)
🍝 Italian Dinner Entrees
Unlike standard takeout joints, Chittenango Pizza offers full dinner entrees. The star of the show here is the Chicken Riggies, a regional dish native to the Utica/Syracuse area that combines pasta, chicken, and peppers in a creamy, spicy vodka sauce.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken Riggies ⭐ | $16.95 | Grilled chicken, vodka sauce, mushrooms, red peppers, onions, banana peppers, and cherry peppers. | 950 |
| Sausage Riggies | $16.95 | The classic Riggies preparation but with savory Italian sausage instead of chicken. | 1050 |
| Chicken Parmesan | $15.95 | Fried chicken cutlet topped with house marinara, mozzarella, and parmesan. Served with pasta. | 850 |
| Eggplant Parmesan | $14.95 | Breaded eggplant slices baked with marinara and melted cheese. | 780 |
| Chicken Broccoli Alfredo | $15.45 | Grilled chicken and broccoli florets tossed in a rich, creamy Alfredo sauce. | 980 |
| Spaghetti | $12.95 | Traditional spaghetti served with house marinara sauce. | 600 |
All dinners are typically served with garlic bread.
🥪 Subs & Calzones
For a handheld lunch, the sub and calzone list provides excellent options. The calzones are essentially folded pizzas stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, while the subs feature toasted rolls and generous fillings.
If you enjoy toasted subs and hearty sandwiches, checking the Johnny’s Pizza menu can provide a good benchmark for pricing and variety in the broader pizza market.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meatball Sub | $10.95 | Homemade meatballs smothered in marinara and melted provolone. | 700 |
| Italian Sub | $11.45 | Salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian dressing. | 650 |
| Chicken Parm Sub | $11.95 | Breaded chicken, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese. | 800 |
| Everything Chicken Sub | $11.95 | Breaded chicken tossed in “Everything” sauce with lettuce and onion. | 850 |
| Cheese Calzone | $8.95 | Ricotta and mozzarella cheese blend. Served with marinara. | 700 |
| Meat Lovers Calzone | $11.95 | Pepperoni, sausage, and bacon stuffed with cheese. | 950 |
| Veggie Calzone | $10.95 | Roasted peppers, mushrooms, and olives with cheese. | 600 |
⭐ Combo Deals & Specials
For families or groups, ordering individual items can add up. The Chittenango Pizza menu offers several “Everyday Specials” that bundle pizzas and wings for significant savings. These deals make Chittenango Pizza a top choice for best value catering for game days or parties.
Comparing these combos to chains like those found on the Pizza Time menu reveals that local spots often offer better volume pricing on wings.
| Combo Deal | Price | Includes | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Family Feast | $30.95 | 2 Large Pizzas | ~$5.00 |
| The Party Pack | $55.95 | 2 Large Pizzas + 24 Wings | ~$10.00 |
| Sheet & Wings | $50.95 | Full Sheet Pizza + 24 Wings | ~$8.00 |
| Medium Combo | $18.95 | Medium Pizza + 10 Wings | ~$4.00 |
| Large Combo | $24.95 | Large Pizza + 10 Wings | ~$4.00 |
Note: Sheet pizzas serve 8–12 people, making them the most economical choice for large gatherings.
🐟 Friday Fish Fry (Seasonal/Weekly)
A staple in Upstate New York culture is the Friday Fish Fry. Chittenango Pizza participates in this tradition with a meal that draws regular crowds.
Fish Fry Dinner – $14.95
- Availability: Every Friday
- Includes: Generous portion of battered whitefish.
- Sides: Hand-cut fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce.
- Add-ons: Hushpuppies or onion rings (+$2.50).
5 Most Popular Menu Items
If it is your first time ordering, these are the items that locals consistently rave about.
1. Chicken Riggies
This isn’t just a pasta dish; it’s a regional identity. Chittenango Pizza’s version uses a vodka sauce that balances the heat of cherry peppers with the richness of heavy cream. It is widely considered one of the menu items you must try.
2. The “Triple Meat” Pizza
For those seeking maximum sustenance, this pizza delivers. The combination of bacon, sausage, and pepperoni provides a salty, savory crunch in every bite. It holds up well for Chittenango Pizza delivery as the heavy toppings keep the heat locked in.
3. Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Rather than a tomato base, this pie uses buffalo sauce and blue cheese. It mimics the flavor of wings without the messy fingers. It is a top pick for football Sundays.
4. “Everything” Wings
Indecisive about sauce? The “Everything” sauce combines elements of BBQ, hot sauce, and garlic parmesan into a sweet, spicy, savory glaze that coats the wings perfectly.
5. Friday Fish Fry
Crispy, golden, and massive. The fish fry is specifically praised for the batter-to-fish ratio-crispy on the outside, flaky and moist on the inside.
📍 Location, Hours & Ordering
Chittenango Pizza operates as a community hub. While they offer a simple dining room, a significant portion of their business is takeout and online ordering.
Address:
Chittenango, NY 13037 (Central Chittenango area)
Estimated Hours:
- Monday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
- Note: Please call to confirm Chittenango Pizza hours as they may shift seasonally.
Delivery & Ordering:
- Phone: Orders can be placed directly for pickup.
- Delivery: Available via major third-party apps (DoorDash, GrubHub) and potentially direct local delivery within a limited radius.
- Payment: Cash and major credit cards accepted. Be aware that some local spots may apply a small service fee for card transactions.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does Chittenango Pizza offer delivery?
Yes, delivery is generally available. You can order through third-party apps like DoorDash or call the restaurant directly to ask about their local delivery radius and fees.
What is the best value item on the menu?
The 2 Large Pizzas + 24 Wings combo for $55.95 is the best value for groups. If dining solo or as a couple, the Friday Fish Fry ($14.95) offers a massive amount of food for the price.
Are there vegetarian options at Chittenango Pizza?
Absolutely. The menu features a Veggie Pizza, Garlic Pizza, Cheese Calzones, and various salads. Pasta dishes like Eggplant Parmesan and Spaghetti Marinara are also meat-free.
What are “Chicken Riggies”?
Chicken Riggies is a specialty pasta dish native to the Utica/Syracuse area. It consists of chicken, rigatoni pasta, and peppers tossed in a spicy, creamy tomato-vodka sauce. Chittenango Pizza is known for their authentic version of this dish.
Do they have gluten-free pizza?
While the menu is extensive, explicit gluten-free crust options are not permanently listed on standard online menus. It is highly recommended to call ahead to check for current gluten-free availability if you have a severe allergy.
Can I order a sheet pizza?
Yes, sheet pizzas are available and are perfect for parties. They typically serve 8 to 12 people. There is a special combo deal that includes a Sheet Pizza and 24 Wings for $50.95.
What comes with the dinner entrees?
Most dinner entrees, such as the Chicken Parmesan or Spaghetti, are served with a side of garlic bread. Some may also come with a small side salad, but it is best to clarify when ordering.
Conclusion
Chittenango Pizza provides a reliable, delicious option for residents of Madison County. From the spicy kick of their Chicken Riggies to the value of their party combos, the menu is designed to satisfy hearty appetites. Whether you are grabbing a Friday Fish Fry or ordering pizza delivery for a movie night, this local gem delivers authentic New York flavor.
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Prices may vary by location and delivery platform. Information verified as of early 2025.
Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Chittenango Pizza menu updates and share it with your friends before your next pizza night!
