Xtrordinary Pizza Menu: Hand-Tossed Pizzas, Subs & Wings
There is nothing quite like the aroma of freshly baked, hand-tossed dough topped with premium ingredients. Whether you are searching for the perfect family dinner in Chula Vista, CA, or looking to feed a hungry crowd in Edgewood, MD, the xtrordinary pizza menu has become a local staple. Known for their generous portions and high-quality “Works” style pizzas, this restaurant offers gourmet flavors without the gourmet price tag.
Our complete guide to the xtrordinary pizza menu provides you with the most up-to-date and accurate pricing, ensuring you never have to guess when planning your meal. Unlike third-party delivery apps that often inflate costs, we break down the exact Xtrordinary Pizza prices you can expect when ordering directly. From their legendary White Truffle Mushroom pie to their crispy mango habanero wings, we cover all the menu items you need to know about. Read on to discover seasonal specials, dietary options, and the best ways to order for your next pizza night.
Complete Xtrordinary Pizza Menu with Prices
Prices may vary slightly depending on whether you are visiting the flagship Chula Vista location or the Edgewood branch. The prices below reflect standard in-store ordering rates.
🏆 Signature Pizzas
All signature pizzas are available in Small (10″), Medium (14″), Large (16″), and X-Large (18″).
The Xtrordinary (Flagship Pie) – $18.99 (S) | $24.99 (M) | $28.99 (L) | $32.99 (XL)
The ultimate combination. Classic red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, bell peppers, red onions, and black olives.
📊 Calories: 280-340 per slice | 🌱 Meat & Veggie Blend | ⭐ Customer Favorite
Meat Lover’s Dream – $19.99 (S) | $25.99 (M) | $29.99 (L) | $33.99 (XL)
A carnivore’s delight featuring pepperoni, Canadian bacon, savory Italian sausage, real bacon bits, and seasoned ground beef.
📊 Calories: 350-420 per slice | 🌱 High Protein | ⭐ Best Seller
Garden Veggie – $17.99 (S) | $23.99 (M) | $27.99 (L) | $31.99 (XL)
A fresh and vibrant pie loaded with fresh mushrooms, green bell peppers, sliced red onions, black olives, and vine-ripened tomatoes.
📊 Calories: 210-260 per slice | 🌱 (V) Vegetarian | ⭐ Light Option
White Truffle Mushroom – $20.99 (S) | $26.99 (M) | $30.99 (L) | $34.99 (XL)
An elevated gourmet option. Creamy garlic sauce base, melted mozzarella, roasted mushrooms, caramelized onions, finished with white truffle oil and fresh parsley.
📊 Calories: 290-330 per slice | 🌱 (V) Vegetarian | ⭐ Staff Pick
BBQ Chicken Blast – $18.99 (S) | $24.99 (M) | $28.99 (L) | $32.99 (XL)
A tangy and sweet masterpiece featuring zesty BBQ sauce, grilled chicken breast strips, red onions, and fresh cilantro.
📊 Calories: 270-310 per slice | 🌱 Poultry | ⭐ Fan Favorite
🍗 Wings & Starters
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buffalo Wings (8pc) | $13.99 | Crispy bone-in wings tossed in Mango Habanero, Lemon Pepper, BBQ, or Classic Buffalo. | 700-850 |
| Buffalo Wings (16pc) | $24.99 | Double order of crispy wings. Customizations: Extra crispy or sauce on the side available. | 1400-1700 |
| Garlic Cheese Knots (6pc) ⭐ | $7.99 | Fresh dough tied in knots, baked golden, tossed in garlic butter & parmesan. Served with marinara. | 540 |
| Garlic Cheese Knots (12pc) | $12.99 | A larger portion of our famous cheesy, garlicky baked dough knots. | 1080 |
| Loaded Potato Tots | $10.99 | Crispy tater tots topped with melted cheddar cheese, bacon bits, jalapeños, and a ranch drizzle. | 890 |
🍝 Pasta & Fresh Salads
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pesto Chicken Penne | $15.99 | Penne pasta tossed in a creamy basil pesto sauce with grilled chicken and sundried tomatoes. | 920 |
| Classic Meat Lasagna | $16.99 | Layered pasta with rich ricotta, mozzarella, and a robust, slow-simmered beef bolognese sauce. | 880 |
| The X-Greek Salad (Small) | $9.99 | Romaine hearts, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives, feta, balsamic vinaigrette. | 320 |
| The X-Greek Salad (Full) | $14.99 | A full-sized portion of our classic Greek salad, perfect as a meal or for sharing. | 580 |
🥤 Beverages & Desserts
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Lava Cake ⭐ | $7.99 | Warm chocolate cake with a molten center, served alongside vanilla bean ice cream. | 650 |
| Cinnamon Knots (8pc) | $8.99 | Sweet version of garlic knots tossed in cinnamon sugar and drizzled with sweet vanilla icing. | 720 |
| Soft Drinks (Regular) | $2.95 | Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Starry, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer. | 0-250 |
| Mexican Coke | $3.75 | Classic Coca-Cola made with real cane sugar, served in a glass bottle. | 150 |
| Dipping Sauces | $0.75 | House-made Ranch, Blue Cheese, Buffalo, Marinara, or Creamy Garlic. | 100-250 |
🧒 Kids Menu (Ages 12 & Under)
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kids 7″ Pizza | $8.99 | Personal-sized pizza with choice of one topping. Includes a small drink. | 450 |
| Cheesy Mac & Cheese | $7.99 | Creamy, kid-friendly macaroni and cheese. Includes a small drink. | 400 |
| Chicken Tenders & Tots | $9.99 | Crispy chicken tenders served with a side of potato tots. Includes a small drink. | 620 |
🌟 Most Popular Xtrordinary Pizza Menu Items
If it is your first time visiting, deciding what to order from the popular dishes list can be tough. Based on local reviews and order volume, here are the absolute must-try items:
- The Xtrordinary Pizza: This is the pie that put them on the map. It offers the perfect ratio of meats to fresh vegetables. It is heavy, filling, and provides the best value if you want maximum toppings per slice.
- Garlic Cheese Knots: The most-added side dish for online ordering. These aren’t just an afterthought; they are baked fresh and generously coated in real garlic butter and parmesan.
- Mango Habanero Wings: Customers rave about the perfect balance of sweet mango and fiery habanero heat. They are consistently ranked among the top customer favorites for game-day appetizers.
- White Truffle Mushroom Pizza: An “Instagram-worthy” gourmet choice that elevates standard pizza night. The truffle oil is fragrant without overpowering the roasted mushrooms.
- Loaded Potato Tots: A unique alternative to standard french fries, these spicy, cheesy, bacon-loaded tots are dangerously addictive.
💰 Xtrordinary Pizza Prices & Value Analysis
When evaluating the cost, Xtrordinary Pizza sits comfortably in the mid-range dining tier. You are paying slightly more than you would at an ultra-budget fast-food pizza joint, but the quality, topping density, and fresh ingredients make it highly worthwhile.
For diners strictly watching their wallets, budget options like Little Caesars menu prices might be cheaper, but they cannot match the hand-tossed, gourmet quality found here. Conversely, if you are used to standard national chains, you’ll find these prices very competitive compared to Pizza Hut menu prices, especially when you factor in the sheer weight of the toppings.
For the ultimate savings, we highly recommend utilizing their combo meals. The Family Bundle ($49.99) saves you approximately $12 compared to ordering two large pizzas, garlic knots, and a 2-liter soda individually.
🥗 Nutrition & Dietary Information
Finding accurate nutrition information for local pizzerias can sometimes be difficult, but Xtrordinary Pizza makes an effort to accommodate various dietary needs.
- Gluten-Free Options: Diners avoiding gluten can substitute a 10″ Cauliflower crust on any small pizza for a $3.50 upcharge. (Note: Because the kitchen uses flour daily, this is not recommended for individuals with severe Celiac disease).
- Vegan Choices: Plant-based eaters aren’t left out. You can request Daiya vegan cheese as a substitute on any pizza for an additional $2.00–$4.00, depending on the size of the pie. The Garden Veggie pizza paired with vegan cheese is a fantastic, cruelty-free meal.
- The “X-Factor” Customization: You can always ask for your pizza to be baked “Extra Well Done” if you prefer a crispier, fold-friendly New York-style undercarriage.
📲 How to Order: Xtrordinary Pizza Delivery & Takeout
For the fastest service and lowest fees, direct online ordering is the way to go. You can place your order through their official website at xtrordinarypizza.com or by utilizing the Toast Tab application.
While Xtrordinary Pizza delivery is available through third-party apps like DoorDash, UberEats, and Grubhub, be aware that menu prices on these apps are generally marked up by 15-20% to cover aggregator commission fees. Ordering directly and picking up your food at their dedicated “Quick-Pick” counter is the best way to keep your bill low.
If you are craving something different, like a massive oven-baked sub sandwich, you might also want to explore Mancino’s menu prices for other hearty takeout ideas in your area!
⏰ Xtrordinary Pizza Hours & Locations
Before you plan your trip, be sure to verify the specific Xtrordinary Pizza locations and their operating schedules. The restaurant maintains excellent consistency, but holiday hours may vary.
Chula Vista, CA (Flagship Location)
- Address: 1392 E Palomar St #401, Chula Vista, CA 91913
- Phone: (619) 216-1111
- Dine-in: Walk-in seating available; no reservations required for groups under 10.
Edgewood, MD (East Coast Hub)
- Address: Pulaski Hwy, Edgewood/Belcamp, MD 21040 (Serving Edgewood, Belcamp, and Abingdon)
- Service: Highly rated for rapid local delivery and fresh takeout.
Standard Xtrordinary Pizza Hours
- Monday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
- Note: Closed on Thanksgiving and Christmas Day. Reduced hours typically apply on Christmas Eve.
🎁 Current Deals & Promotions
Finding great restaurant deals is easy if you know when to order. Xtrordinary Pizza frequently runs promotions to reward local, loyal customers:
- The Daily Lunch Special: Available every day from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM. Get two large slices of Pepperoni or Cheese pizza plus a regular fountain drink for just $9.99.
- Military Discount: The Chula Vista location honors a 10% discount for all active-duty military and veterans with a valid ID.
- Loyalty Program: By creating an account on their ordering portal, you can earn “X-Points” for every dollar spent, which can be redeemed for free garlic knots, desserts, or discounts on your next pizza.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does Xtrordinary Pizza have gluten-free options?
Yes, they offer a 10″ cauliflower crust for a $3.50 upcharge. However, because pizzas are prepared in a shared kitchen, there is a risk of cross-contamination, so it is not recommended for those with severe Celiac disease.
What is the best value item on the menu?
The Family Bundle is the best value deal. For $49.99, you receive two large one-topping pizzas, an order of 12 garlic knots, and a 2-liter soda, saving you around $12 compared to buying everything separately.
Can I order Xtrordinary Pizza delivery to my hotel?
Yes! Both the Chula Vista and Edgewood locations frequently deliver to nearby hotels and business parks. You can use their direct website or apps like DoorDash to coordinate a lobby drop-off.
Does the restaurant offer vegan cheese?
Yes, Xtrordinary Pizza offers Daiya vegan cheese as a substitute. You can add it to any pizza for a small upcharge of $2.00 to $4.00, depending on the size of the pie.
What are the busiest times to visit or order?
Peak hours are typically Friday and Saturday evenings between 5:30 PM and 8:00 PM. If you are ordering during this window, expect delivery and takeout times to be slightly longer.
Is there a kids menu available?
Yes, the restaurant caters to families with a dedicated kids menu featuring an $8.99 7-inch personal pizza, cheesy mac & cheese, and chicken tenders. All kids’ meals include a small fountain drink.
[Xtrordinary Pizza interior dining room showing happy customers eating at booths, warm lighting, modern rustic decor + professional lifestyle photography + candid, inviting atmosphere]
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice. Prices may vary slightly by location and are subject to local taxes. Information verified March 2026.
Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Xtrordinary Pizza menu updates, deals, and local delivery information.