Nico’s Pizza West Allis Menu with Current Prices
Famous for its Signature Garlic Bread and authentic pizzas made with premium Wisconsin Grande Mozzarella, Nico’s Pizza in West Allis offers a menu packed with flavor. Whether you’re craving a classic pie, a hearty grinder, or a shareable appetizer, this guide has the complete Nico’s Pizza West Allis menu to help you decide. We keep this page updated with the latest prices and offerings for your convenience.
Complete Nico’s Pizza West Allis Menu with Prices
Below you will find the full menu with Nico’s Pizza West Allis prices for every item, from their famous starters to their specialty pizzas and hot subs. All prices have been verified to ensure accuracy.
🍽️ Appetizers
Start your meal off right with one of Nico’s delicious appetizers. The garlic bread is a must-try, but the mozzarella medallions are a cheesy delight perfect for sharing.
| Menu Item | Price | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Nico’s Signature Garlic Bread ⭐ | $9.54 | Garlic bread served with rich marinara sauce. A great option to add cheese for extra flavor. |
| Basket O’ Fries | $7.14 | A generous portion of crispy, perfectly seasoned fries. |
| Nico’s Powerhouse Buffalo Thighs (Spicy) | $16.20 | Flavorful and spicy buffalo-seasoned chicken thighs. |
| Fresh Mozzarella Medallions | $15.60 | Breaded and fried rounds of fresh mozzarella served with a side of dipping sauce. |
🍕 Pizzas
Nico’s pizzas are crafted with a premium Grande Mozzarella Asiago cheese blend and high-quality toppings. Each pizza is available in a 12-inch or 14-inch size to suit any appetite. These are some of the most popular dishes on the menu.
| Pizza Name | 12″ Price | 14″ Price | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Classic | $19.50 | $28.20 | A traditional pizza featuring the signature Grande Mozzarella Asiago blend, tomato sauce, and classic toppings. |
| The Tasty Firecracker (Spicy) | $20.50 | $28.20 | A spicy pizza loaded with hot peppers and other zesty toppings for a fiery kick. |
| The Portnoy | $17.00 | $24.00 | A savory signature creation with a delicious blend of select meats and cheeses. |
| The Catania | $19.50 | $28.20 | An Italian-inspired pizza made with fresh, traditional ingredients that evoke classic flavors. |
| The Magnificent Portobello w/ Sausage | $19.50 | $28.20 | A rich and earthy pizza combining savory portobello mushrooms and Italian sausage on a cheesy base. |
🥪 Grinders (Hot Subs)
Nico’s Grinders are hearty, hot-pressed subs packed with fresh ingredients. From the popular Chicken Parmigiana to the classic Philly Steak, there is a grinder for every taste.
- Chicken Parmigiana Grinder – $8.50 ⭐
Breaded chicken smothered in marinara sauce and topped with melted cheese. A true customer favorite. - Philly Steak Grinder – $9.99
Tender steak sautéed with fresh onions and mushrooms. - Homemade Meatball Grinder – $8.50
Classic homemade meatballs in sauce, topped with melted cheese. - Buffalo Chicken Grinder (Spicy) – $8.99
Chicken sautéed in hot sauce with a tomato base. - Italian Combo Grinder – $8.50
A classic combination of Italian cold cuts, served hot. - Vegetarian Grinder (V) – $9.99
Packed with a variety of fresh vegetables for a healthy and filling option. - BBQ Chicken Grinder – $8.99
Chicken sautéed in smoky BBQ sauce with a tomato base. - BLT Grinder – $8.50
A classic grinder with bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, and hot peppers. - Chicken Cutlet Grinder – $8.50
- Grilled Chicken Grinder – $9.99
- Italian Sausage Grinder – $8.50
- Eggplant Parmigiana Grinder – $8.50
- Ham, Salami, Turkey, Pepperoni, or Cooked Salami Grinder – $8.50 each
- Ham & Egg, Bacon & Egg, or Sausage & Egg Grinder – $9.25 each
Most Popular Nico’s Pizza West Allis Items
Not sure what to order? Here are the top menu items that customers rave about, offering the perfect introduction to Nico’s flavor.
- Signature Garlic Bread: The perfect starter for sharing. It’s crispy, buttery, and even better when you add cheese.
- The Classic 12″ Pizza: Offering the best value and timeless flavor, this pizza is a huge hit with families and first-time visitors. It showcases the quality of their premium Wisconsin cheese blend. For another great pizza option, check out the Pizza Time menu.
- Chicken Parmigiana Grinder: This hearty sub is consistently rated as one of the best grinders, known for its generous portion size and authentic taste.
- The Tasty Firecracker Pizza: If you love a spicy kick, this pizza is for you. It’s loaded with heat and flavor.
- Fresh Mozzarella Medallions: An indulgent and satisfying appetizer that’s perfectly fried and wonderfully cheesy.
How to Order from Nico’s Pizza West Allis
Getting your favorite pizza and grinders is easy. Nico’s offers several convenient ways to order for any occasion.
- Online Ordering: The fastest way to get your food is through online ordering. You can place your order for pickup or delivery directly from their official website or via third-party platforms.
- Delivery: Nico’s Pizza West Allis delivery is available through major services like DoorDash, Grubhub, Seamless, and Uber Eats.
- Phone Ordering: Call ahead to place your carryout order at (414) 316-9557.
- Dine-In: Visit the restaurant to enjoy a meal in their dining room or book their private party space for an event.
Current Deals & Promotions
Currently, there are no publicly advertised restaurant deals or combo meals. However, Nico’s Pizza West Allis offers excellent value with its generous portions and high-quality ingredients. For events and large groups, inquire about their private party buffet options, which can provide great value for catering.
Nico’s Pizza West Allis Hours & Location
You can find Nico’s Pizza conveniently located on West National Avenue. The restaurant provides a comfortable setting for dine-in guests and an efficient hub for takeout and delivery orders.
- Address: 9638 W. National Avenue, West Allis, WI 53227
- Phone: (414) 316-9557
Nico’s Pizza West Allis hours are typically from late morning to evening, but it’s always best to call or check online for the most current times.
- Monday – Sunday: Approximately 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
The West Allis location also features a private VIP Party Room that can accommodate up to 70 guests, complete with buffet options and a bartender, making it one of the best Nico’s Pizza West Allis locations for hosting events.
Nutrition & Dietary Information
Nico’s Pizza West Allis provides several options to accommodate different dietary preferences.
- Vegetarian Options: The Vegetarian Grinder is a popular choice, and customers can build their own vegetarian pizzas.
- Spicy Options: Menu items with a kick, like the Powerhouse Buffalo Thighs and The Tasty Firecracker pizza, are clearly marked.
- Allergen Information: Currently, detailed nutrition information such as calorie counts or specific allergen guides are not publicly available. If you have a severe allergy, it is recommended to speak with the staff directly when placing your order.
For those looking for other diverse pizza options, the Halal Pizza Point menu offers unique choices.
Frequently Asked Questions about Nico’s Pizza West Allis
What are the most popular menu items at Nico’s Pizza West Allis?
The most popular dishes include the Signature Garlic Bread, The Classic pizza, and the Chicken Parmigiana Grinder. These items are consistently highlighted as customer favorites.
Does Nico’s Pizza West Allis deliver?
Yes, Nico’s Pizza offers delivery through third-party services like DoorDash, Grubhub, Seamless, and Uber Eats. You can place an order directly through their respective apps or websites.
Are there vegetarian options on the Nico’s Pizza West Allis menu?
Yes, Nico’s offers a Vegetarian Grinder and the ability to customize pizzas with a variety of vegetable toppings to create a vegetarian-friendly meal.
What are the hours of operation for Nico’s Pizza West Allis?
The typical Nico’s Pizza West Allis hours are from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM daily. However, it’s always a good idea to call ahead or check their online profiles for the most up-to-date hours.
How much does a pizza cost at Nico’s Pizza West Allis?
Pizza prices vary by size and toppings. A 12″ specialty pizza generally ranges from $17.00 to $20.50, while a 14″ specialty pizza ranges from $24.00 to $28.20.
Does Nico’s Pizza West Allis have a party room?
Yes, the West Allis location has a private VIP Party Room that can host up to 70 people. It’s a great option for parties, meetings, and other events, with buffet options available.
Can I order online from Nico’s Pizza West Allis?
Yes, online ordering is available through the official Nico’s Pizza website and various third-party delivery partners, making it easy to order for either pickup or delivery.
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items subject to change. Prices may vary by location and ordering platform. Information verified November 2025.
Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Nico’s Pizza West Allis menu updates. For another great local option, consider exploring the Johnny’s Pizza menu.