Legacy Pizza and Bakery Menu with Prices – New Albany IN
Searching for the official Legacy Pizza and Bakery menu online can be frustrating. Most results only show scattered reviews or outdated photos. This family-owned gem in New Albany, Indiana, doesn’t publish a full digital menu, but we have compiled the most complete and current guide available to help you decide what to eat before you call.
Known for their “East Coast Style” dishes, this spot has quickly become a local staple since opening in 2020. Whether you are craving their famous Bacon Jam Pizza, a massive Stromboli, or fresh homemade cheesecake, this guide covers it all. Below, you will find the full breakdown of Legacy Pizza and Bakery prices, including their build-your-own pizza options starting at just $7.00.
Why Locals Love It
Unlike big chains, Legacy offers homemade bakery items prepared daily. Their unique offerings, like the Pull-Apart Bread and hand-tossed crusts, set them apart. Plus, with family-friendly pricing-like combo meals often coming in under $40 for a group-it offers some of the best value in the Kentuckiana area.
🥖 Appetizers & Starters Menu
The starters here are heavy on comfort. The “Pull-Apart” breads are the signature item, perfect for sharing. The portion sizes are generous, often doubling as a small meal for lighter eaters.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pull-Apart Bread ⭐ | $8.00 | Lightly seasoned pull-apart style breadsticks, served with a side of pizza sauce. | Ask Server |
| Pull-Apart Cheese Bread | $9.00 | Fluffy breadsticks baked with melted Mozzarella, served with pizza sauce. | Ask Server |
| Bruschetta Bread | $10.00 | Pull-Apart Bread topped with Feta, Romano, Mozzarella & Tomatoes. Served with housemade Garlic Butter. | Ask Server |
| Sausage Rolls | $8.00 | Two croissant-sized pizza dough rolls filled with Italian Rope Sausage & Mozzarella. | Ask Server |
| Pepperoni & Cheese Rolls | $8.00 | Two croissant-sized pizza dough rolls stuffed with Pepperoni & Mozzarella. | Ask Server |
| Bacon Jam Appetizer ⭐ | $13.00 | A 10” pizza crust topped with sweet Bacon Jam, Feta, Mozzarella, Romano, Peppadews, and Balsamic Drizzle. | Ask Server |
| Breadsticks | $5.00 | Classic breadsticks, baked fresh. | Ask Server |
| Cheese Bread | $6.00 | Classic bread topped with melted cheese blend. | Ask Server |
🍕 Pizza Menu (Build Your Own & Specialty)
Legacy offers a high level of customization. You can stick to a budget-friendly cheese pizza or go all out with a “Premium” creation. The dough is hand-tossed daily. If you are looking for a national chain comparison for pricing, you might check Little Caesars menu prices, but Legacy offers a distinct homemade quality you won’t find at fast-food joints.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12″ Cheese Pizza | $7.00 | Hand-tossed base. Add toppings for ~$1.00 each. | Ask Server |
| 16″ Cheese Pizza | Varies | Large hand-tossed base. Toppings extra. | Ask Server |
| Premium Small Pizza | $14.00 | Chef’s choice specialty toppings (e.g., Bacon Jam style or Supreme). | Ask Server |
| Premium Large Pizza | $20.00 | Large signature pies loaded with premium ingredients. | Ask Server |
| Bacon Jam Pizza ⭐ | ~$14-22 | The full-size version of their famous appetizer. Sweet and savory. | Ask Server |
Note on Customization:
- Crust: Hand-tossed.
- Toppings: Standard options include Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions, Peppers, Olives, and Spinach.
- Sauce: Their standard marinara is highly rated by locals.
🌯 Calzones & Stromboli Menu
If you prefer your toppings on the inside, the Stromboli here is cited by many reviewers as the “best in New Albany.” They lean toward an East Coast style, ensuring the filling-to-dough ratio is substantial.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14″ Stromboli ⭐ | $10.00 | East Coast style. Popular fillings include beef, Mozzarella, and mustard sauce. | Ask Server |
| 20″ Stromboli | $18.00 | A massive portion suitable for sharing. | Ask Server |
| Small Calzone | ~$13.00 | Stuffed with Ricotta and Mozzarella. Includes up to 3 toppings (e.g., Spinach, Chicken). | Ask Server |
| Large Calzone | Varies | Roughly the size of two small calzones. | Ask Server |
🥐 Bakery & Desserts Menu
Unlike Pizza Hut menu prices where desserts are often pre-packaged, Legacy lives up to the “Bakery” part of its name. Items are homemade daily and stock is limited-when they sell out, they’re gone for the day.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheesecake ⭐ | $6.00 | Rich, creamy, and made in-house. A customer favorite. | Ask Server |
| Cannolis | $4.00 | Crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cream. | Ask Server |
| Bread Loaf | $5.00 | Freshly baked loaf of bread to take home. Similar quality to Great Harvest menu prices. | Ask Server |
| Cookies / Brownies | Varies | Selection varies daily. | Ask Server |
🥗 Salads, Subs & Pasta
While specific prices for these categories fluctuate based on market ingredients, Legacy Pizza and Bakery offers a selection of fresh options beyond pizza.
- Salads: Fresh garden salads are available as sides or entrees.
- Subs: Hot subs featuring Italian meats and cheeses.
- Pasta: Rotating pasta specials are common, often featuring homemade sauces.
- Secret Menu Tip: Ask about the “Chef’s Choice” or daily specials when you call.
🔥 Most Popular Legacy Pizza and Bakery Items
If you are a first-time visitor, these customer favorites are the safest bets for a great meal.
- Bacon Jam Pizza/Appetizer ($13+)
This is the item that put them on the map. The combination of salty bacon jam, tangy balsamic glaze, and sweet peppadews creates a flavor profile you won’t find elsewhere. - 14″ Stromboli ($10)
A high-value item. For just ten dollars, you get a substantial meal filled with high-quality meats and cheeses. - Homemade Cheesecake ($6)
Reviewers consistently mention that you should “save room for dessert.” It’s dense, creamy, and visibly handmade. - Pull-Apart Bread ($8)
Fun to eat and perfect for families. The accompanying pizza sauce is robust and flavorful.
📍 Legacy Pizza and Bakery Hours & Locations
Legacy Pizza and Bakery currently operates a single location. They are closed Sunday and Monday, so plan your cravings accordingly.
Address:
1001 Vincennes St, Suite 100
New Albany, IN 47150
Phone:
Call the restaurant directly for takeout orders. (Check local listings for the current number).
Legacy Pizza and Bakery Hours:
| Day | Operating Hours |
|---|---|
| Tuesday – Saturday | 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
📱 How to Order (Dine-In & Takeout)
This establishment focuses on traditional service. Here is how you can get your food:
- Dine-In: They offer table service with a cozy, family-friendly vibe. Reservations are accepted and recommended for Friday/Saturday nights.
- Takeout: This is a very popular option. Call ahead to place your order.
- Delivery/Online Ordering: Currently, Legacy Pizza and Bakery delivery is not officially listed on major apps like DoorDash or UberEats. It is best to call for curbside pickup or takeout.
- Payment: They accept Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express.
🎉 Current Deals & Promotions
Looking for the best value? Keep an eye out for these money-saving opportunities:
- Build-Your-Own Value: Starting at $7 for a 12″ cheese pizza is incredibly competitive for handmade pizza.
- Gift Card Deals: Historically, they have offered promotions like “$20 gift card for $10” during holiday seasons. Check their social media for active offers.
- Family Meals: With large pizzas and affordable appetizers, a family of four can often eat for under $40.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What are the Legacy Pizza and Bakery hours?
Legacy Pizza and Bakery is open Tuesday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM. They are closed on Sundays and Mondays.
Does Legacy Pizza and Bakery offer delivery?
They primarily focus on dine-in and takeout. There are no official first-party delivery services listed, so you will need to pick up your order at their New Albany location.
What are the best Legacy Pizza and Bakery prices for lunch?
The 12″ cheese pizza for $7.00 is an excellent lunch option. You can also grab a 14″ Stromboli for just $10.00.
Are there vegetarian options on the menu?
Yes! The Pull-Apart Bread, Bruschetta, Cheese Bread, and build-your-own pizzas/calzones can all be made vegetarian.
Do they sell gluten-free pizza?
Currently, there is no specific gluten-free crust listed on the standard menu. We recommend calling the restaurant directly to ask about allergen-friendly options.
Is the cheesecake really homemade?
Yes, the desserts, including the cheesecake, cannolis, and cookies, are made fresh in their bakery section daily.
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Prices may vary by location. This information was verified as of December 2025 based on available data.
Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Legacy Pizza and Bakery menu updates.