Knapp Street Pizza Menu with Current Prices
The aroma of a fresh-baked Neapolitan thin crust is unmistakable when you walk into this beloved Sheepshead Bay staple. For years, locals have considered the “Gold Standard” cheese pie at this neighborhood joint to be a true Brooklyn classic. Whether you are a long-time resident of Marine Park or just visiting the area, finding the most accurate knapp street pizza menu is essential before you place your next order.
This comprehensive guide provides a fully updated 2024–2025 price list, highlighting everything from their trending Grandma Pie to hearty Italian heroes. We also break down exactly how to get the best value by avoiding third-party delivery app markups. With our complete breakdown, you will know exactly what to expect before you take your first bite.
Complete Knapp Street Pizza Menu with Prices
We have carefully verified all menu items so you can plan your family dinner or weekend game-day feast. All standard pies are available as a Large (18-inch), ensuring a filling meal that’s big enough to share.
🍕 Signature & Specialty Pizzas
Regular Cheese Pie – $21.00
Classic Neapolitan style with signature tomato sauce and premium melted mozzarella on a perfectly thin crust.
📊 Calories: ~280 per slice | 🌱 (V) Available | ⭐ Customer Favorite
Sicilian Pie – $24.00
Thick, square-cut crust that is airy on the inside with a crunchy bottom, topped with heavy sauce and mozzarella.
📊 Calories: ~350 per slice | 🌱 (V) Available | ⭐ Customer Favorite
Grandma Pie – $26.00
Thin crust square pie, layered with fresh mozzarella, spotted with savory marinara sauce, fresh garlic, and basil.
📊 Calories: ~310 per slice | 🌱 (V) Available | ⭐ Staff Pick
White Pizza (Bianca) – $25.00
A creamy mozzarella and ricotta cheese blend with a touch of garlic and virgin olive oil (no tomato sauce).
📊 Calories: ~320 per slice | 🌱 (V) Available
Buffalo Chicken Pizza – $30.00
Spicy breaded chicken pieces, mozzarella, and a heavy drizzle of spicy buffalo sauce and cooling blue cheese.
📊 Calories: ~410 per slice | 🌶️ Spicy | ⭐ Local Favorite
Knapp Street Special – $32.00
The ultimate “everything” pie loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, mushrooms, peppers, and onions.
📊 Calories: ~450 per slice | 🥩 Meat Lover’s Choice
(If you love exploring different regional pizza styles, check out our guide on Mario’s Woodfired Pizzeria Menu for a contrasting artisanal take on classic pies.)
Appetizers, Heroes & Pasta
🍗 Appetizers & Side Orders
Garlic Knots (6) – $4.00 / (12) – $7.50
Freshly baked dough tied in knots, tossed in virgin olive oil, fresh minced garlic, and parsley.
📊 Calories: ~120 per knot | 🌱 (V) Available | ⭐ Must-Order Side
Mozzarella Sticks (6) – $9.50
Crispy, golden-fried cheese sticks served with a side of homemade dipping marinara sauce.
📊 Calories: ~540 per serving | 🌱 (V) Available
Buffalo Wings (10) – $14.50
Juicy chicken wings with your choice of Mild, Hot, or BBQ sauce. Served with celery sticks and blue cheese.
📊 Calories: ~850 per serving | 🌶️ Spicy Available
Fried Calamari – $16.00
Tender, golden-fried calamari rings served with fresh lemon wedges and zesty marinara.
📊 Calories: ~400 per serving | 🐟 Seafood
Zucchini Sticks – $9.00
Breaded and fried crispy, providing a great vegetable crunch, served with tomato sauce.
📊 Calories: ~350 per serving | 🌱 (V) Available
🥖 Hot Heroes & Sandwiches
All heroes are served on fresh-baked, crusty Italian bread.
Chicken Parmigiana Hero – $13.50
Crispy breaded chicken breast smothered in homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
📊 Calories: ~850 | ⭐ Top Selling Sandwich
Meatball Parmigiana Hero – $12.50
Traditional homemade Italian meatballs covered in rich tomato sauce and melted cheese.
📊 Calories: ~900 | 🥩 Classic Choice
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero – $12.00
Thinly sliced, lightly breaded eggplant layered with melted cheese and marinara sauce.
📊 Calories: ~700 | 🌱 (V) Available
Philly Cheesesteak – $14.00
Thinly sliced steak grilled with onions and bell peppers, topped with melted American cheese.
📊 Calories: ~820 | 🥩 Hearty Meal
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero – $15.50
Fried jumbo shrimp perfectly paired with tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella on a toasted roll.
📊 Calories: ~780 | 🐟 Seafood
🍝 Italian Entrées & Pasta
All pasta dishes are served with fresh bread. Choose from Spaghetti, Penne, or Linguine.
Penne alla Vodka – $15.50
Al dente penne tossed in a creamy pink sauce with a touch of prosciutto and onions. (Add Grilled Chicken +$4.00)
📊 Calories: ~750 | ⭐ Customer Favorite
Baked Ziti – $14.00
Ziti pasta mixed with rich ricotta and tomato sauce, then baked under a thick layer of melted mozzarella.
📊 Calories: ~680 | 🌱 (V) Available
Fettuccine Alfredo – $16.00
Classic Italian pasta tossed in a rich, buttery white cream sauce with grated parmesan cheese.
📊 Calories: ~900 | 🌱 (V) Available
Chicken Francese or Marsala – $19.00
Tender chicken breast in either a lemon-butter sauce or savory mushroom wine sauce, served over pasta.
📊 Calories: ~800 | 🍗 Dinner Specialty
(Looking for more traditional Italian pasta and starter inspiration? Review the Guido’s Pizzeria & Tapas Menu for comparative dishes.)
🥟 Rolls & Calzones
Cheese Calzone – $8.50
Fresh pizza dough generously stuffed with a blend of ricotta and mozzarella. Add extra fillings for $1.50 each.
📊 Calories: ~600 | 🌱 (V) Available
Chicken Roll – $9.00
Breaded chicken cutlet pieces, tomato sauce, and mozzarella securely wrapped and baked in pizza dough.
📊 Calories: ~650 | ⭐ Quick Lunch Pick
Sausage, Pepper & Onion Roll – $9.00
A hearty blend of Italian sausage, roasted peppers, and sweet onions rolled in fresh dough.
📊 Calories: ~700 | 🥩 Meat Lover’s Choice
🥗 Sides & Salads
Garden Salad – $9.50 (Sm) / $12.50 (Lg)
Crisp lettuce mixed with ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, and red onions.
📊 Calories: ~150 | 🌱 (VG) (GF) Available
Caesar Salad – $10.50
Fresh Romaine lettuce topped with crunchy croutons, parmesan cheese, and creamy Caesar dressing.
📊 Calories: ~350 | 🌱 (V) Available
Side of Meatballs (3) – $8.00
Three large, homemade Italian meatballs served in marinara sauce.
📊 Calories: ~450 | 🥩 Protein Add-on
French Fries – $6.00
A generous portion of crispy golden fries. Add melted cheese for an additional $1.50.
📊 Calories: ~400 | 🌱 (V) Available
🥤 Beverages & Desserts
| Item | Price | Description |
|---|---|---|
| 20 oz Soda | $2.75 | Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Sunkist |
| 2-Liter Soda | $4.50 | Perfect for family pizza nights |
| Snapple / Stewart’s | $3.00 | Assorted classic glass bottle flavors |
| Bottled Water | $2.00 | Cold spring water |
| Cannoli | $4.50 | Crisp shell freshly filled with sweet ricotta cream |
| Zeppoles (6) | $5.00 | Hot, fried dough bites dusted with powdered sugar |
Most Popular Knapp Street Pizza Items
If it is your first time visiting, you cannot go wrong with these standout popular dishes that keep the Brooklyn locals coming back week after week:
- The Grandma Pie: This is arguably the crown jewel of the menu. The balance of fresh garlic, sweet basil, and savory marinara on a perfectly thin square crust makes it a massive seller.
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero: Built on high-quality, freshly baked Italian rolls, this hero perfectly balances the crispy breaded chicken with an ideal ratio of sauce to melted cheese.
- Buffalo Chicken Slice: The undisputed go-to for the afternoon lunch crowd. It provides a massive kick of heat mellowed out by a creamy blue cheese drizzle.
- Garlic Knots: Universally considered a must-order side item. They are soft on the inside, crispy on the outside, and generously coated in fresh garlic and olive oil.
- The Sicilian Pie: Known as the best “square” in the 11229 zip code, this pie offers a thick, airy dough that boasts an incredibly satisfying crunch on the bottom crust.
(For another perspective on highly-rated Brooklyn slices, you might want to read our breakdown of the Stefano’s Brooklyn Pizza Menu.)
Knapp Street Pizza Prices & Value Analysis
When evaluating Knapp Street Pizza prices, the restaurant falls comfortably into the affordable $-$ $ range. They provide premium, authentic Brooklyn quality without inflating costs. A standard large cheese pie at $21.00 is highly competitive for the Sheepshead Bay and Marine Park area.
If you are looking for the absolute best value, you should look into their standard Family Special. For just $29.99, families get a Large Pie, 12 Garlic Knots, and a 2-Liter Soda. Furthermore, you will secure the lowest possible prices by ordering directly via the restaurant’s phone number or through their official Slice app integration, entirely avoiding the hidden service fees typical of massive third-party apps.
Nutrition & Dietary Information
For guests monitoring their diet, we have compiled basic nutrition information to help you make informed choices. While traditional Brooklyn pizza is an indulgent treat, there are lighter options available.
The Garden Salad is an excellent, low-calorie choice, especially when paired with a side of grilled chicken for added lean protein. For vegetarians, the White Pizza (Bianca), Eggplant Parmigiana, and Cheese Calzones offer meat-free comfort food. Guests with severe dairy or gluten allergies should always call the shop directly to inquire about cross-contamination practices, as flour is heavily present in the kitchen.
How to Order from Knapp Street Pizza
Whether you are hosting a party or just need a quick Tuesday night dinner, getting your food is simple. For the fastest service and most accurate pricing, calling the shop directly at (718) 646-6014 is recommended. Walk-in pickup orders are typically hot and ready within 15 to 20 minutes.
If you prefer online ordering, the restaurant officially partners with the Slice App. Using Slice allows you to earn “Pizza Points” for future discounts while providing real-time tracking. Knapp Street Pizza delivery covers a generous 2 to 3-mile radius, reliably serving Sheepshead Bay, Marine Park, and Gerritsen Beach neighborhoods. While they are available on DoorDash and Uber Eats, ordering direct is the smartest way to save money.
Knapp Street Pizza Hours & Location
Located in the heart of southern Brooklyn, this family-owned independent business is easy to access. Street parking is generally available, and there is a small lot nearby for quick pickups.
Address:
2101 Knapp St
Brooklyn, NY 11229
Phone: (718) 646-6014
Knapp Street Pizza hours are consistent throughout the week, catering to the lunch rush, dinner crowds, and late-night cravings on the weekend.
| Day | Operating Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Friday – Saturday | 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM |
Holiday Schedule Note: The restaurant is closed on Thanksgiving and Christmas Day, but remains open late to serve the community on Super Bowl Sunday.
Current Deals & Promotions
To help loyal customer favorites stay affordable, the pizzeria runs several ongoing promotions. Checking out these restaurant deals is a great way to feed a crowd on a budget.
- Daily Lunch Special: Get 2 Regular Slices and a 20 oz Soda for only $8.50. This deal runs daily from 11:00 AM until 4:00 PM.
- The Family Special: 1 Large Cheese Pie, 12 Garlic Knots, and a 2-Liter Soda for $29.99.
- Loyalty Rewards: Customers who use the preferred Slice App automatically accumulate points toward free items and exclusive discounts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Knapp Street Pizza deliver?
Yes, Knapp Street Pizza delivery is available within a 2 to 3-mile radius of their location, covering Sheepshead Bay, Marine Park, and Gerritsen Beach.
What is the best pie at Knapp Street Pizza?
While the classic cheese is fantastic, most locals heavily recommend the Grandma Pie for its perfect garlic and basil ratio, or the Knapp Street Special if you want a fully loaded meat and veggie pie.
Does Knapp Street Pizza have vegetarian options?
Yes, they offer many vegetarian-friendly dishes. The White Pizza (Bianca), Eggplant Parmigiana Hero, Cheese Calzones, and Garden Salads are all excellent meat-free choices.
What are the peak hours for the restaurant?
Friday and Saturday nights between 5:00 PM and 8:00 PM are the busiest times. It is highly recommended to place your weekend dinner orders slightly ahead of time.
How can I get the cheapest price on my order?
The best way to secure the lowest prices is by ordering directly. Call the restaurant at (718) 646-6014 or use their official Slice app portal rather than third-party aggregators that add high delivery fees.
Does the restaurant accept mobile payments?
Yes, the storefront accepts major credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, AMEX, Discover) as well as modern mobile payments like Apple Pay and Google Pay at the counter. Cash is always preferred and avoids minor credit card surcharges.
Do they offer catering menus?
Yes, they offer half-trays and full-trays of their popular pasta dishes, salads, and heroes for local Brooklyn events. You will need to call the shop directly to set up a catering order.
Is there seating available inside?
Yes, there is limited casual dine-in seating featuring a few counter spots and booths. No reservations are required, as it operates as a standard, fast-casual neighborhood pizzeria.
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items subject to change. Prices may vary by location and delivery platform. Information verified October 2024 (projected through 2025/2026).
Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Knapp Street Pizza menu updates, and enjoy your next slice!