Fire on the Bayou Menu with Prices & Locations (2025 Guide)
Craving the spice of authentic crawfish boils or the comfort of a rich gumbo? The Fire on the Bayou menu brings the heart of New Orleans straight to Central Florida. Whether you are visiting the Orange City location or the spot in New Smyrna Beach, this restaurant is known for its scratch-made Cajun cuisine and lively atmosphere.
This guide provides the complete, up-to-date menu, including Fire on the Bayou prices, popular items, and nutritional estimates. From the massive “Bucket of Love” to the crispy Gator Bites, here is everything you need to know before you order.
🦐 Boils & Buckets Menu
The star of the show at Fire on the Bayou is the seafood boil. Each bucket is boiled fresh with signature spices and served with corn and potatoes. You can customize your spice level from Mild to “Extra Spicy.”
Signature Buckets
Bucket of Love – $57.00
The ultimate shareable feast. Includes 2 lbs crawfish, 1 lb shrimp, 4 snow crab clusters, Andouille sausage, corn, and potatoes.
📊 Calories: ~1,200 (Shareable) | 🌶️ Custom Spice Level | ⭐ Staff Pick
Jilly Bucket – $36.00
Perfect for date night. 1 lb crawfish, ½ lb shrimp, 2 snow crab clusters, sausage, corn, and potatoes.
📊 Calories: ~700 | 🌶️ Custom Spice Level | ⭐ Best Seller
Mardi Craws – $25.00
1 lb crawfish boiled with Andouille sausage, corn, and potatoes.
📊 Calories: ~500 | 🌶️ Custom Spice Level
Shrimp Bucket – $22.00
1 lb boiled shrimp with Andouille sausage, corn, and potatoes.
📊 Calories: ~550 | 🌶️ Custom Spice Level | 🏆 Best Value
A La Carte Boils
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snow Crab Clusters | $38.00 | Boiled crab with sausage, corn, potatoes | 600 |
| Crawfish Boil Sampler | $22.99 | 1lb crawfish, ½lb shrimp, 2 crab clusters | 650 |
| Shrimp (Half lb) | $13.00 | Smaller portion with sausage and corn | 275 |
| Shrimp (Full lb) | $20.00 | Full pound with sausage and corn | 550 |
🍤 Starters & Appetizers
Start your meal with traditional bayou flavors. The Kickass Sausage Bites are a unique “must-try” item you won’t find elsewhere.
Popular Starters
Kickass Sausage Bites – $11.99
Andouille sausage marinated in pepper jelly, served on New Orleans bread with Gorgonzola and balsamic.
📊 Calories: ~450 | ⭐ Customer Favorite
Fried Green Tomatoes – $12.99
Crispy fried tomatoes topped with rich Cajun cream sauce and tender crawfish.
📊 Calories: ~520
Gator Bites – $13.99
Authentic Louisiana alligator tail meat, fried golden and served with remoulade.
📊 Calories: ~480
Crab Étouffée Dip – $13.99
Creamy, warm crab dip served with house-made tortilla chips.
📊 Calories: ~600 (Shareable)
Catfish Bites – $11.99
Bite-sized fried catfish pieces served with jalapeño tartar sauce.
📊 Calories: ~450
🥪 Po’ Boys & Sandwiches
All po’ boys are served on authentic French bread with a side of fries and coleslaw. These are substantial menu items perfect for lunch or dinner.
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Second Line Po’ Boy ⭐ | $20.00 | Fried shrimp & crawfish with remoulade | 700+ |
| Mahi Sandwich | $22.99 | Grilled mahi fillet with Cajun tartar | 620 |
| Catfish Po’ Boy | $16.99 | Fried catfish with tartar and pickles | 650 |
| Shrimp Po’ Boy | $15.99 | Fried shrimp with remoulade sauce | 600 |
| Buffalo Chicken Sandwich | $19.54 | Fried/Grilled chicken in buffalo sauce | 650 |
| Traditional Burger | $14.94 | Beef patty, Cajun mayo, standard fixings | 550 |
🍝 Entrees & NOLA Classics
For those wanting a fork-and-knife meal, these classics feature dark roux and slow-cooked ingredients.
NOLA Sampler – $22.99
Can’t decide? Get a taste of everything: Jambalaya, Red Beans & Rice, and Gumbo.
📊 Calories: ~750 | ⭐ Best Way to Try Everything
Shrimp and Grits – $21.99
Creamy stone-ground grits topped with sautéed Gulf shrimp in a savory sauce.
📊 Calories: ~680
Seafood Jambalaya – $19.99
Rice dish cooked with shrimp, crab, crawfish, and Andouille sausage.
📊 Calories: ~600
Chicken & Sausage Gumbo – $16.99
Traditional dark roux soup with chicken, sausage, okra, and rice.
📊 Calories: ~450
Fish and Chips – $18.00
Golden fried fish fillet served with Cajun coleslaw and fries. (Look for the Monday Special on this item!)
📊 Calories: ~700
🥔 Sides & Extras
Complete your meal with these Southern staples.
- Red Beans and Rice – $5.00
- Potato Salad – $4.00
- Cajun Coleslaw – $4.00
- French Fries – $4.00
- Extra Corn or Potato – $1.50
🎂 Desserts
Don’t leave without trying the beignets-fried dough covered in powdered sugar, a New Orleans icon.
- Beignets (Order of 3) – $7.00
- Bread Pudding with Rum Sauce – $7.00
- Key Lime Pie – $7.00
🧸 Kids Menu
Simple options for the little ones.
- Kids Chicken Tenders with Fries – $8.00
- Kids Burger with Fries – $8.00
5 Most Popular Fire on the Bayou Dishes
If you are visiting for the first time, these popular dishes are the highest-rated by regular customers.
- Bucket of Love: The ultimate social meal. It feeds 2-3 people and offers a massive variety of seafood.
- Kickass Sausage Bites: A surprisingly complex appetizer. The mix of spicy sausage, sweet jelly, and tangy Gorgonzola is a flavor bomb.
- NOLA Sampler: The best value for solo diners. You get three distinct entrees on one plate, making it a great introduction to Cajun food.
- Fried Green Tomatoes: The crawfish cream sauce on top elevates this from a standard Southern side to a gourmet appetizer.
- Beignets: Fresh, hot, and covered in sugar. It is the only proper way to end a meal here.
Fire on the Bayou Locations & Hours
Fire on the Bayou operates two main locations in Volusia County. Check the Fire on the Bayou hours below before heading out.
New Smyrna Beach Location
- Address: 1500 S Dixie Freeway, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168
- Phone: (386) 427-1111
- Hours:
- Mon-Thu: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Fri-Sat: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sun: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
Orange City Location
- Address: 921 Town Center Dr, Orange City, FL 32763
- Phone: (386) 775-1111
- Hours:
- Mon-Thu: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Fri-Sat: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sun: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
(For fans of Southern cuisine, check out our guides for Parish Grill Menu Prices and Duke’s BBQ Menu.)
How to Order: Delivery & Takeout
You have several options for online ordering if you prefer to eat at home.
- ToastTab (Recommended): The official direct ordering system for the restaurant. This usually has the most accurate prices and lowest fees.
- Delivery Apps: Fire on the Bayou is available on DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub. Note: Prices on apps may be slightly higher than in-store.
- Call Ahead: You can call the numbers listed above to place a takeout order directly.
Tip: Seafood boils travel okay, but fried items (like Gator Bites or Po’ Boys) are best enjoyed fresh at the restaurant for maximum crispiness.
Deals & Happy Hour
Looking for restaurant deals? Here is how to save money on your visit:
- Happy Hour: Mon-Fri from 3:00 PM – 6:00 PM. Features discounted appetizers (often $5) and drink specials.
- Monday Fish & Chips: A weekly special offering a discount on the Fish and Chips platter.
- Loyalty Program: Sign up with your phone number to earn points on every dollar spent. Rewards include free appetizers and discounts.
Nutrition & Dietary Information
While Cajun food is rich, there are ways to navigate the menu for different diets.
- Gluten-Sensitive: The seafood boils (without corn/potatoes if worried about cross-contamination) are naturally gluten-free. Avoid the roux-based Gumbo and Étouffée.
- Vegetarian: Options are limited but include Red Beans & Rice (ask for no sausage), Potato Salad, and Beignets.
- Calorie Conscious: Stick to the boiled shrimp or grilled Mahi sandwich (hold the bun/sauce) for lower-calorie options.
(Also see: Cottonfield Bar and Grill Menu for more comfort food options.)
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Fire on the Bayou have a kids menu?
Yes, they offer kid-friendly staples like Chicken Tenders and Burgers, both served with fries for around $8.00.
Is Fire on the Bayou spicy?
The restaurant allows you to customize your spice level on boils. For other dishes, the “Cajun spice” is moderate-flavorful but not overwhelming. If you are sensitive to heat, ask your server for “Mild.”
Do they take reservations?
Fire on the Bayou primarily operates on a first-come, first-served basis. However, for large parties (10+ people), it is highly recommended to call the location ahead of time.
Does Fire on the Bayou deliver?
Yes, Fire on the Bayou delivery is available through major third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats. You can also order takeout directly through their website.
What are the vegetarian options?
Vegetarian options include Beignets, salads (without meat), Corn, Potatoes, and Red Beans & Rice (request vegetarian preparation).
Is there outdoor seating?
Both the New Smyrna Beach and Orange City Fire on the Bayou locations offer patio seating, which is perfect for enjoying a messy seafood boil when the Florida weather is nice.
Disclaimer: Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Prices may vary slightly between the Orange City and New Smyrna Beach locations. Information verified as of December 2025.
Found this helpful? Bookmark this page for the latest Fire on the Bayou menu updates.